Should I test for iron deficiency before supplementing?+
Yes. Ferritin (iron stores) and transferrin saturation are the usual tests. Taking iron without a confirmed deficiency risks iron overload, especially in men and postmenopausal women. In a randomised trial in non-anaemic menstruating women with low ferritin, iron reduced fatigue more than placebo (Vaucher 2012, CMAJ). Take iron at least 4 hours apart from levothyroxine and 2–3 hours apart from tetracycline antibiotics; take quinolone antibiotics at least 2 hours before or 6 hours after iron. Acid-suppressing medicines such as PPIs reduce absorption. Keep iron out of reach of children: iron overdose can be fatal in young children.
What is the best B12 form?+
NICE uses oral cyanocobalamin for diet-related deficiency and hydroxocobalamin injections for absorption problems or any neurological symptoms (seek prompt care). Test before supplementing: high-dose folic acid can hide the anaemia of B12 deficiency while nerve damage progresses.
Is CoQ10 worth taking if I'm not on a statin?+
The qualifying evidence is mainly for statin-associated muscle symptoms (a 2018 meta-analysis in J Am Heart Assoc). For otherwise-healthy adults, the evidence that CoQ10 improves energy is weak. CoQ10 may reduce the effect of warfarin and may lower blood pressure, so discuss it with your doctor if you take either kind of medicine.
Korean ginseng vs rhodiola: which adaptogen for energy?+
Both have EMA HMPC monographs: Panax ginseng for symptoms of fatigue and weakness, and rhodiola as a traditional herbal medicine for temporary relief of stress symptoms such as fatigue. Neither has strong trial evidence. Ginseng can be stimulating and disturb sleep, may raise blood pressure and lower blood glucose, and interactions with warfarin are documented. Rhodiola can also be activating and is best avoided in bipolar disorder.
Does creatine help non-athletes?+
The EU-authorised claims are about exercise: 3 g a day increases performance in short bursts of high-intensity exercise, and in adults over 55, 3 g a day enhances the effect of resistance training on muscle strength. Research on cognition and brain energy is early and mixed. Vegetarians get less creatine from diet. People with kidney disease should not take creatine without medical advice, and creatine raises blood creatinine, which can be misread on kidney tests.
Is American ginseng different from Korean ginseng?+
Same genus (Panax), different species: American ginseng is P. quinquefolius, Korean ginseng is P. ginseng. A standardised North American ginseng extract (CVT-E002) reduced colds in some trials; the evidence is limited. Ginseng may affect warfarin INR; avoid in pregnancy.
What is the evidence for ALCAR (acetyl-L-carnitine)?+
The 2019 Cochrane review (Rolim) of acetyl-L-carnitine for diabetic peripheral neuropathy was very uncertain whether it reduces pain, as the evidence is sparse and of low certainty. The evidence for chronic fatigue and cognition is smaller still. It may reduce the action of thyroid hormone and can cause restlessness or insomnia.
What does alpha-lipoic acid actually do?+
It is an antioxidant and mitochondrial cofactor. The trials are in symptomatic diabetic peripheral neuropathy at 600 mg/day orally: symptoms improved versus placebo in the SYDNEY 2 trial, while the 4-year NATHAN 1 trial did not influence its primary endpoint. In Germany alpha-lipoic acid is an approved pharmacy-only medicine for this use. It can cause hypoglycaemia with insulin or other antidiabetic medicines.
Does shilajit actually raise testosterone?+
There is no evidence that meets our standard that shilajit raises testosterone; the one qualifying trial looked at muscle fatigue. Quality is the practical limit: heavy-metal contamination (lead, arsenic, mercury) has been documented in unpurified shilajit. Avoid with iron-overload disorders and in pregnancy and breastfeeding; it may lower blood glucose and blood pressure.